So far so good.  We received this blanket a few days ago and my wife seems to like it.  The material this blanket is a little noisy when moving around, but definitely not a deal breaker.  The weight, which is a true 12lbs, is evenly distributed and stays in place.  My wife won't admit to liking this as much as she probably does, but goes straight for it every night, so I think it's a good sign.  Would recommend and for the price we bought it at ($62 for 48"x72") on Way Day, it was a steal.