So these stools were a second choice as the ones I've wanted and been waiting for to come back in stock on Wayfair is taking too long (months too long).  Anyway, I do like these stools.  The grey is a perfect shade that goes well with my kitchen, chairs are sturdy and swivel, and it has a metal foot rest in the front which is great.  The height works well with my island.  Chairs were easy to assemble.  The only thing I'm not a big fan of is that the back of the chair is on an angle so it doesn't rest at a straight 90 degrees on your back - you lean back a bit when in the chair.  Since these were bought to eat at the island, I don't care for the "lean back" feature, but some people might.  Otherwise these are great chairs - no complaints and would recommend.