The black leather tub chairs are just what I wanted and would have got a five star rating except for the ripped interfacing at the bottom front of one of the chairs. It had ripped out from the staples or might not have been properly stapled in the first place. Either way it escaped quality control. I considered returning said chair but the problem is fixable but it should not have happened; just a little bit of tarnish to the Wayfair ethos.