I had to order twice because of a change in plans. The first (largest) order were thin and I had to use white-out to cover up the overlap here instructions on each tile. However, they looked nice and went up well. When I had to reorder one additional box, they were different. Luckily they were placed one other side of the room, but they were very hard to cut, slightly different in size and feel like they are rubber, in contrast to the smooth feel of the other. PS. I ordered from the reorder feature, so they should have been the same.