I was very pleased with the color of the cushions, very pretty!  The size was accurate, and quality of sewing seems to be good.  However, although the size shows 4" thick, it didn't seem very firm.  After only using them a couple times, you could clearly see an indention where you sat, so the size was reduced to 2" very quickly.  Also, they hold water pretty badly.  Every time it rains, I have to take them off my chairs and hang them in order to get the water out.  I've never had to do this with other cushions.