Does the job. Looks ok (from the front). Feels super cheap. Seam in back leaves a gap. SO TINNY.
PROS: Fits large rolls with ease. Looks OK from afar.
CONS: Feels super cheap and sounds so tinny. Like a gong when you touch it.

If I didn't already have a very nice metal cylindrical TP holder (the same basic concept) in a different room I might think this one was great. But the one I already had feels solid and well made. Alas, I got that older one many many years ago and perhaps they just don't make them like that any more (I've looked and I finally took a gamble on this one). So it's OK, I was just hoping for something that felt more solid.