We received this set in January and have been enjoying it for the past 2 weeks since it's gotten warmer outside.  We're very happy with the gray color of the wicker, and the quality overall seems to be very high.  It wasn't too bad to get the set put together.  The cushions are just ok, a bit thin with very thin fabric, but considering the price this is fine.  We expect to need to replace them after a year.  Overall the chair and loveseat are comfortable to sit in and feel very solid.  We're sad to see it's been discontinued, as we've considered buying another set.  We bought covers to try to reduce the likelihood of rust, as this looks like the source of most of the negative feedback.  We're very happy.  Excellent price, great quality!!