Conceptually? Wonderful! Clean and simple which is exactly what I was looking for. 
Generally? Frustrating to construct, but I appreciate the varied drop length. 
Aesthetically? Massive room for improvement. The each candle was constructed at a different angle and so all the shades sit crooked. In a different style it might be fine but this was designed to be clean & simple lines, so it just looks like a Dr. Suess reject. It would be a 4-star product if I could manually bend it into place but it's so deep in the construction I risk breaking it.