These are great stools especially for the price. Lost a star because one stool had a nailhead missing but Birch Lane replaced it immediately with no questions asked. A on customer service. 
Look like solid wood from a distance with a bit more rustic look than I expected but pretty nonetheless. Feel and sound like manufactured wood, which is what I ordered so no surprises there. Very happy with the comfort level and sturdiness. We are not smallpetite people and sit comfortably for evenings of entertainment with no discomfort. Would recommend.