I'd give it a 3 1/2 stars if I could.  I wanted a chair for my bedroom with a standard height seat - Something to sit on while I tied my running shoes.  The seat is very firm and it's not the type of chair you'd sink into to read a book while sipping hot cocoa. But, it does the job.  Assembly was easy.  I did it by myself in under an hour.  The hardware is packaging is idiot proof.  My complaint is the back cushion.  It was crushed down in a small bag rather than being laid out flat.  The fabric is very wrinkled and the pillow wont fluff up.  Maybe after a few weeks it will relax.    Everything else was packaged very well.  Also, the seam on the front of the seat has a noticeable wave in it too that I cant get to straighten out.