We bought the "natural". I would give this 3.5*, keeping in mind we got it on heavily discounted closeout pricing. I would not be happy with this/wouldn't recommend this at full price. 

Pros: feels substantial. The height is good when so many console tables are too short. It arrived in good condition. 

Cons: we built it very carefully but the drawer is misaligned and so the top scrapes and there is a gap at the bottom. It does open and close with some force but since this is just laminated wood it won't be functional for us as the scraping to open and close will likely peel the laminate off eventually. So we can't use the drawer which was one of the features we bought it for.

In the closeup photo you can see little lines in the laminate. These are also on the top. They make it quite obvious that it's laminate not real wood aside from those, I liked the color and finish.