I think the chair is really cute! I didn't have any tears or damage upon delivery. The color is great (I purchased the "brown" color). I was also able to assemble the chair pretty easily on my own. One of the wheels was giving me fits not wanting to push in all the way but eventually got it. I am 5'3' and with the chair at full height or even just a tad lower, works just fine with my new desk. The "depth" of the seat is perfect, just at the bend of my knees where my back actually reaches the back of the chair to provide the perfect support (no high back that feels like it is pushing you forward). I also weigh 130 lbs and the width of the chair is great too, not tons of space on either side so my arms rest perfectly. Love it. The ONLY thing that stinks is that I bought this chair about 5 days ago and now it is $30 off (darn the luck).