I bought this one 6 months ago. It looked really nice when we got it out of the package. It is a bit darker that it appears in the picture so that was a draw back but the bars on the side are such a nice detail that I didn't care that much. I have three kids and specially the 3 year old is really though on the furniture. So it has already some scratches but they don't really show unless you look at it really up close. Great piece for the money. 

Pros: beautiful, scratches don't show
Cons: it is darker than in the picture