The quality of these stools are wonderful.  Seats are just a tad rough, but it is reclaimed lumber, so that is to be expected and it goes with the look I was looking for in my kitchen.  The stools are very sturdy and have a wide seat base.  I love how stable they are for all of the kiddos who are at my table.  One of the stools was damaged and I just went through the replacement process which was very easy.  Once I get my undamaged stool, I will be extremely pleased.