These would easily get 5 stars if the sewing and/or quality control was better.  I love the color, the tone on tone color is just what I was looking for. The material is good, not overly soft, but not stiff either.  The zipper works fine. But a good 1-2 inch end portion of the pillow arrived without being stitched together.  It is something I'll be able to fix, but I purchased already made pillows so that I wouldn't have to sew.  Definitely a disappointment.