It did the trick of keeping my new young dog from ruining the existing sofa fabric but the color was not as pictured.  The camel color has no gold tones at all.  It is definitely a blah tan color which was disappointing.  It shifts on the sofa after someone has been sitting on it so you have to tuck it back in place each time.  It was a short term solution for me so I did not seek a refund.  If I planned to use them longer I would have though due primarily to the color problem.