So once these chairs were assembled, they seem decent. Nice swivel, even color in fabric, although there are several spots on the underside of the chair bottom and arms where the metal color is uneven. The three stars are due to assembly. These chairs almost broke me. I’ve put together TONS of furniture before and these two chairs were the first items where I thought, you know, I might not actually be able to get them together. The holes in the arms and the chair back are so misaligned that I had to bend the metal to get the screws in. So misaligned that I kept looking at the directions sure that I was doing something wrong. But nope, they’re just manufactured sloppily. It took me 45 min per chair to assemble! It should have been no longer than 15 minutes. Maybe I just got a bad lot Idk. But if not, bring your patience, strong hands, and a buddy when trying to wrangle these together.