I'd give this a 3.5, maybe 3.75 stars if there was the option. It's attractive looking and is pretty similar to the picture. I chose the "Linen" color. Initially, I thought it was too dark but once you open it up the color lightened up. A word about that- the material is pretty thin so be mindful if you're trying to cover a dark couch with a light colored cover. You may need something with a bit more thickness or darker color. It does come out of the package extremely wrinkly so I threw mine into the dryer and used the "Dewrinkle" setting my dryer has. There's definitely a learning curve in terms of getting it on and some rubber grips here and there helps to keep things in place (I have a leather couch). It's not a custom fit to my couch but it beats buying a whole new couch!