They are definitly sharp out of the box. But I have only used them a couple times so I can't speak for longevity. The handles look a little sloppy which is the reason for the 4 stars. It's nothing deal breaking just something noticeable when you look closely at the craftsmanship. Overall so far it seems like a good starter set. I received them as a gift and am happy with them, they make a good second set for when you don't want to pull out the expensive knives.