So... overall these are nice chairs, nice oatmeal color, seem comfortable.  But the reason for the 3 stars is the difficulty in putting them together!!! UGH.  Took me several hours (by myself) to get 6 of these put together.  I was using only the tools provided, so maybe there is an easier way.  If so, the instructions should have stated that.  And I have to say, I really normally enjoy putting furniture together and have never really had as much headache as these chairs.  Ok... I'll stop complaining because I think the end result is pretty good! :)