Nice curtains, but the pattern does not align properly in the middle when the curtains are closed. I like the material weight and sheen, and the pattern colors are beautiful. However, I bought these because the description said they were lined and insulated. They are neither. The material is heavy-weight but they are not thermal-insulated in any way. They ought to have been about half the price. I'd give it two stars for that reason alone, but they are a nice quality curtain for non-insulated use.