As someone mentioned earlier, the black paint is not a high sheen, but rather a softer luster (always wanted to use that word).  They look great, so why the 4 stars?  One of the stools is slightly wonky/crooked/askew, which may add to the unique quality of the item depending on your perspective; however, I'm a bit Monk, so it bugs me a little.  

Furthermore, the wood stains easily unless sealed, although a quick rub with some fine sandpaper and it's good as new.  The top locks down fine, which others have complained about.  That said, a rambunctious urchin will easily unlock it by spinning counterclockwise.  It's a futile effort to get them to stop.  

For this price point, you really can't go wrong.