These are excellent quality. One of the black hoops for the base was a little scuffed up, but it's not noticeable. The rest of the product was intact and completely damage free and I was impressed with the packaging. They're super comfy and easy to assemble.  We're going to buy two more to complete our bar...unfortunately we only need one so  be on the lookout for one of these on craigslist unless they are sold separately as well!