It isn't the quality or appearance that rates a 3 for me, it is the fact that it is too small for my cats.  They don't use it.  I purchased a larger one (kitty condo bench) at the same time and they love it.  If you have one, small cat, this item may work for you but if you have more than one and they are used to a large litter box, this is not a safe bet.  I will probably turn mine into storage or a bed for them instead.