It has a nice aesthetic and is pretty easy to assemble. It also includes a clever method to mark where you need to put holes in the wall which I appreciate. I knock a star off for two reasons. One, because some of the stickers to cover the screw holes were bent so they struggle to stay in place. Two, and more importantly, keep in mind that this mounting mechanism will not be flush with the wall. The brackets are a few millimeters thick and also you're hanging it onto screws that are mounted into the wall. So your shelf will be away from the wall by at least 3-5mm which, depending what angle you look at it, can be aesthetically unpleasant.