We have had this set for 10 years.  It still looks as good as new.  We get compliments on them all the time (that standing knife is always a topic of conversation!).  I’ve seen some bad reviews, I have to wonder how they’ve been cared for - the directions state never to use a citrus soap on them, we use an uscented gentle soap, first six years in dishwasher, last four by hand so I think either is fine.  They seriously still look perfect.  We’ve lost a few now with kids so will be buying more of the same!  Can’t say enough great things!!