Im torn between a 3-4 star, I really like the tray and its size and color. But man is this thing off. the bottom is fine but the top bar with the handle is so crooked. I mean bad! I had thought about returning it but my husband was able to add a washer and tighten it more and it seems to not be so noticeable. The other thing is the top you have to have the right amount of weight divided or its off. Im not sure if that's just how the tiered trays are or if its just this one this is the only one Ive ever bought. Also it did have a pretty strong odor, but once out off the box and able to air out it did go away. Again the color is great and the size is perfect for my counter and Rae Dunn. Once decorations have been added its very cute.