I honestly would have given this bookcase 5 starts if not for the lack of instructions and The way that some of the legs don’t match.  This bookshelf is very sturdy and heavier then most bookshelves it’s size, speaking of the size the shelves are spacious and spaced out enough for larger ￼items to be displayed on it.  There was a scratch on one shelf that I think will be easy to buff out.  The colors are very nice the wood doesn’t look like cheap manufactured wood and the black metal frame is a dark black matte finish witch is nice.  I would definitely recommend this product especially since I believe the imperfections will be easily disguised.