This is a solid piece of furniture.  My only disappointment was that it was significantly darker than it appeared in the online image.  There was a minor defect in the wood, but in an inconspicuous location and I could easily disguise it.  I am keeping it because the price was low and if I find something better I won't feel badly about relegating this to the curb or Goodwill.  Also, the fees to return it were extremely high and not worth the aggravation.  

Pros: Good value, easy assembly, fast delivery
Cons: Darker than depicted, small damage, $$$ for returns