I just received this and I'm scoring a 4 since I haven't had a chance to use.  This seems like a high quality dutch over. It's sturdy and the top fits really well for a good seal while cooking.  The only thing I'm not happy about is the color.  I viewed this on two computers and the color was more vibrant but when i received it it's more of a blue ombre with the center of the top is medium blue, the edge of the top is a dark blue.  The body of the dutch oven is the same as the top.  It starts off medium and gradually get's darker.  Other than the color, I'm pleased with my order.