Two stars for the color of the aged barrel. It is not a graybrown like the image in the website. It very gray with a greenish hue. The coverage of the stain is inconsistent.  Minus one star for Wayfair’s new refund policy that requires the customer to pay return shipping and pick up charges. I would have exchanged for a different color but wasn’t given exchange as an option. So, not only am I out return shopping, the price to replace this with a different color is more than 50 more than what I originally paid last week during the sale.  I won’t be reordering.