I bought this fireplace screen door 2 years and it's still holding strong and I don't have any complaints.    The color looks much darker than what it shows in the picture, but it still looks good on my fireplace.   The screen doors are sturdy and keep the cold air out when not in use.  Make sure you insulated around the screen door.. 

Pros: Well finished and sturdy
Cons: Color isn't exactly the same as in the picture