I won't know until Christmas, this was bought as a present for my daughter and I am hoping it's okay.  I haven't unpacked it.  One corner is slightly dented in, but it looks minor.  I don't hear any clinking like broken glass.   I will say I'm pleased with how well the item is packed.   I didn't want to have any mishaps with delivery so I ordered early before snow and icy conditions would make it hard for delivery.