There were multiple comments regarding the lack of comprehensive directions so that was no surprise.  It was not difficult to figure out how to put together.  My reasons for only 3 starts are - back of the chairs are a dull brown.  They do not shine like they shine in the picture.  Both chairs have scratches/small dings around the wood area.  Also, there are two strips of tape on the back of each chair covering the screws.  When I pulled the tape off, it removed part of the finish on one of the chairs and there is no pen included to color that in so I have a white spot (visible) on the top of my chair.  Also, both the chairs and the table are wobbly.  The bottoms of the legs to do not adjustable screw in pieces so you can level them.  So overall, I'm ok with it, but not thrilled which is disappointing for the cost.  

Pros: Overall matches picture
Cons: no way to adjust table or chairs so they are not wobbly