I would give it a 3.5 but rounded down since its really not worth 4 stars. It came with finish chipped off in a few spots, and once hung, is crooked. Tried to adjust the chain links in several ways to straighten it out, and it got slightly better, but the bottom is still not parallel with the floor. The entire thing weighs nothing, which makes it easier to hang than a more substantial chandelier, but it feels chintzy. Also, it is not a deep black color, it is more muted/charcoal. It appears to be a CHEAP KNOCKOFF buy from another site and spend slightly more and get a higher quality fixture.