Not sure how to rate these, really. I ordered the Smoke color in 54x80 size. When they arrived, the curtains measured 36x54, although the package said 54x80. Spoke to customer service. Replacement curtains were sent out immediately. Same problem. Called customer service. Was told that the 2nd set of replacement curtains would be checked before being sent out. They arrived promptly. Same problem. The curtain itself is a lightweight fabric that would probably serve well in most applications. We ordered these for a screened porch so, size issue aside, they seem too lightweight to work well in breezy conditions.