These stools look good.  They fit with the other rustic furniture in our kitchen. But for counter height stools, they are about 1 or 2 inched too high.  Great for my 3 year old son, but less than ideal for an adult with thick legs.  I might run them through a table saw if guests start complaining.

I ordered 4 of these.  Unfortunately, one is different than the others.  The finish is slightly different and so is the construction.  Although, I don't think anyone will actually notice since they are tucked under an island.  But still, if I order 4 chairs there is an assumption they will all match!