I like this product from a 10 foot perspective, but it fails up close.  First the good.  The laminate has a great look, the assembly was very simple and the stability is sound.  The missing star was primarily due to the manufacturing and shipping processes.  The drilling operation was not clean in all cases causing some breakout.  I needed to be selective in which shelves went where.  I also assume that even though the packaging was tight I still had minor scratches.  I don’t like the extra holes, which I assume may be for connecting adjacent cabinets. The black plugs stand out when it falls on a grey area.  
This product is a design and good value for the price, but falls short of the 5 star rating due to minor defects in the execution.