I ordered these for a bathroom reno and they haven't been installed yet, but they are solidly built, the finish is smooth and even across all surfaces, and the shade fits securely into the lamp.  So far, they seem to be a very good value for the price, and I am looking forward to installing them in my new bathroom!  The shipping took a bit longer than expected...about 10 days from order to delivery, but that was not a problem since construction hasn't started yet.  But be aware, if you are on a deadline.