These chairs were exactly what we were hoping for. We did order two from the Open Box section and while they claim to inspect them and be in unused and good condition, one of the chairs has a broken cap on the leg. Literally hanging on by a tiny piece/thread. Knew there were no returns available and took a chance to save some $$$, but will not be doing that again as it's not worth it. Want these stools for a long time and this just decreased the chance. Will try and fix somehow, but still disappointed. 

Other than that - they're rustic looking and a good brown color (mine were not skewing orange like others claimed). A piece of one of the seats did chip a little as it got caught on some shorts, but we're just fixing it ourselves.