First, lost one star for shipping with FedEx - they left my box outside the gate on the sidewalk, and kept changing my delivery date.
Second, lost another star as several of the pieces had paint that was chipping and a few pieces had chips in the wood. One of the shelves was breaking apart - used wood glue to fix the problem.  The door and drawer needed to be refit so that they properly fit. 

Despite those things this shelf is awesome, it is exactly what we were looking for and solved our storage problems. Also really love the color.