As before, one plate has a defect in the face part of the dish. I have purchased two sets of 12 and this set of four plates. Two plates out of the 16 had small defects. Wayfair sent out replacements for the first dish, twice, which was kind. However, each dish was more defective than the previous. So I suppose that two small plate defects are ok and not worth the hassle of more peanuts and boxes.