I'm on the fence about her. She's extremely photogenic. She doesn't look completely different from her pictures, but she is definitely working the angles. All the tree angels I've ever owned have interesting proportionsand gangly arms, so her weird hands don't bother me. I would have given her 4-5 if not for the screw in her back. I made the mistake of putting my hand in her ... the under her dress area ... and the screw stabbed my finger (it's sharp!). Honestly, it's weird enough to be sticking my hand up there in preparation for tree decorating season, but come on! Anyhow, not sure if I'm going to keep her or not. She's beautiful but deadly.