My only criticism of this chair is that it needs just a little more padding on the seat.  I am 6'3" and 225 and my shoulders come to the top of the chair but I only use this as a computer chair and I do not lean back in it.  I have also only used the leg rest twice and only just to see if it was useful and it can be.  For me I can rest my calves on it so if I really wanted to rest my legs for longer than a few minutes I would probably buy an ottoman or foot rest but for short durations it is fine.  I am definitely happier with this chair over several others in this price range and easily earns a 4 star rating.