Upon opening the box there were multiple damages to the top of the desk and to the under side.  The only part that was pre-assembled as assembled incorrectly so I needed to take it apart and re-assemble so that it matched the instructions (the curved support was at the back in stead of the front, it's curved so your legs fit under it).  If it wasn't damaged and if it had been correctly assembled then I'd have given it 5 out of 5 but unfortunately it missed the mark.