This would have been a five, but I was disappointed to see a dented corner.  It is small and one of the back ones, so I decided to keep even though it will probably break off and I will have to repair. Also, did not know how we could ship back.  I don't think it happened in shipping, because it was packed very well in Styrofoam.  Otherwise, it is very sturdy and fits well under the window.  Serving as an end table and storage.  Just was hoping for no defects with the price we paid.