The first set I opened was perfect. Would have rated them 5 stars. The second set each had a flaw--one was in the seagrass weave and the other had about 1/2 inch on the back of both legs that had no stain. That brought the rating down to a 3. I suppose I should have reported the flaws and have the chairs replaced but they were out of stock for so long that I didn't want to deal with it.