I've only had the stools for 4 days now, but so far I like them.  They were a little tedious to assemble (about 3 hours for all 4 stools), but you get faster after the first one.  Some of the holes didn't align on the legs and had to be redrilled.  One of the seat cushions had more of a gap in the back than it should have but hopefully, it's not too noticeable.  The faux leather is OK.....I would have preferred to pay more for real leather, but only time will tell how it holds up to use.  We don't have any kids at home anymore, so they won't be used daily.  All of the nail heads were present.  They seem pretty comfortable but then I'm replacing my wicker seat stools, so that's a big difference.  I really like the look of these stools overall and am happy with my purchase.