Check all your measurements - under counter height, space between each stool for comfortable access, space behind the counter to allow easy pull out and finally how long you think you will sit. We chose the Aisha stool because it fit all our measurements, it has clean lines and is easy to wipe down.  We sat in our new purchases last night for dinner for about an hour and they were very comfortable. 
We didn't want four "look at me" stools consuming the whole area. The Aisha stool slides tidily under our counter height of 34", width of 95". I bought the 3-year protection plan just because our family will be using these chairs daily.  The first image of the chair is indoors. The last image is under sunlight to show the chair color.  Hope this detail helps.