I gave this only 4 stars because it wasn't the right shade of gray for my bedroom...I wanted it to match my bed and I couldn't decide between the gray and the silver, and Wayfair couldn't send me swatches.  So I got the gray and it's too dark so I probably should have ordered the silver.  Also, the loop at the front to open the lid tore off the first day, which isn't a huge deal to me because I didn't like the way it looked anyway (I think it looks cheap), but it speaks to the quality of this item.  Lots of storage inside though, and the half-moon design is more interesting than a straight bench.  It's also pretty sturdy...I weigh 190 and it holds me no problem.