Ok. The box sat in the closet for 2 months waiting on Christmas.  The chairs seem to be good quality for the price.  Check back with me in a couple of years to be sure. I have one suggestion on the assembly instructions.  Have a note when it says to attach the rails the back piece that says ensure hole in the middle of the rail is pointing up.  I promise you if its not and you keep going, it is a nightmare to tighten and then loosen because you will have to take the entire chair back apart to fix it.