Was initially concerned when moving the boxes around it sounded like something was loose or rattling inside. When I took out the contents to assemble, there was a ton of rust and either metal or paint filings. I was worried that there was a serious issue. However, once I knocked out the debris (whatever it was - some was definitely rust) and inspected it, the stools are sound. They assemble easily and feel pretty sturdy. The cushion seems a little cheap - very squishy and the vinyl cover seems like it would crease or tear. However, they have held up pretty well and are reasonably comfortable as long as you don't sit on them for several hours at a time. I'm still suspicious of the cushions, but so far, so good. They look great in our kitchen.