The bookcase actually has a wonderful rustic quality and I love the look but one of the shelves was actually split and broken off on delivery and I have yet to get a response back from wayfair. It glued together fairly well and it is facing the wall so not completely noticeable. One other thing to note - the shelf height is actually pretty low and I discovered a lot of my textbook/manuals do not fit so will probably need another shelf. 

Pros: lovely rustic look and nice design and color (bit more gray than in picture)
Cons: broken on delivery; shelf height a bit to short