One of the boxes had been opened, there was a big dent on the bookshelf headboard, the flat panel that goes behind was unattached. Obviously someone returned that box because of the damage and there is no quality check because they sent me the same box. My husband took two hours to assemble it and he was almost finished he saw the big dent on front. We are keeping it because it was too much work to put it together, so we will live with the damage. They know one customer returns, they send it to the next customer without fixing it, maybe the next customer will not notice it until they spent two hours putting it together and they will keep it anyway. Well that's what happened to us. I am giving one star because they should not have sent me a box that was previously open without at least fixing the problem.