It does the job and holds all of my leftover Christmas wrap.  I wasn't sure if the door was going to close, but with a little finesse, it actually does. I use only small ribbon spools on the top bar because the larger ribbon spools bump into the wall when opening the door all the way. Not a huge issue. Good, decent product. I chose this one because the others I compared this to were too short in length for a standard roll of wrapping paper. This one fits my wrapping paper rolls perfectly. I would recommend, but don't expect anything high quality or fancy. It simply does the job.