So far so good! The material is much softer than I expected. Very comfortable and rocks and swivels smoothly. The recliner is comfortable but as others have said it does take some force to push the recliner back down into place. I like that the recliner handle is inside the arm rest so you don't have to reach around. It has a deep seat--I am 5' 8" and my feet just touch the floor--I could see this being a bit of an issue for shorter people. 
Our baby hasn't arrived yet, so I'm not sure how it will be for late nights of baby rocking and nursing, but I'll try to update later! 
Overall pretty happy with the quality considering we purchased online without being able to touch or test it.