4 STARS Because it is lighter than expected. If I had kids in the house I would not have ordered these for my Sunroom.  However! These are stunning! I put an amber bulb in and it creates a gorgeous evening ambience. It reminds of light the sun cast right before it goes all the way down. Hence both of these lamps are in our Sunroom. Very classy, elegant, with a naturalness due to the lamp shade. When searching "forever" I either would love the lamp and hate the lamp shade or vs. This checked every box except the overall weight. Yes I would still recommend.