I wanted to love these. If they looked like the pictures, I'm sure I would have. We ordered two and one was definitely defective. It looked like the process quality control was lacking. Wayfair, as always, replaced it immediately, but the replacement was so different than the first lamp that it has left me wondering if this is the lamp for us. I get that the pieces are like art work, and may vary slightly, but they should still look like a set. I would not recommend, unless you like guessing at what your lamps will look like.