Just finished putting this together - it looks great and sturdy. the instructions are comparatively well done (very few undos, and good warnings to things to pay attention to, including half screwing etc.) The package arrived wet and a few parts were chipped but they are locate in non-visible areas. However a large part that was supposed to be nailed and glued came off, when looking at it the nails never went in but were bent under. As i did not want to go through customer service i unbent and rehammered with a cloth so as not to damage. 4 stars