Update: Manufacturer contacted me within a couple hours and is sending a replacement piece. Nice job Wayfair Customer Service! 

Super disappointed…arrived messed up - and not in acceptable condition to be assembled. Super disappointed as I know have to wait for Wayfair and/or manufacturer to make this right. How did this get past quality control!? I hope this is a fluke and it is replaced/made right by Wayfair/manufacturer as I read such great reviews.