I had a similar quilt from Nautica for the past few years. As with everything else these days, the quality of this replacement is HORRIBLE. Thin, cheaply made, faded colors. I am pretty sure the only thing about this that is actually from Nautica  is the tag sewn on by some sweatshop thousands of miles away.  Wayfair knock-offs have plummeted into the disposable housegoods department, that is to say might as well throw it in the trash when you receive it