I bought these because I needed a slimmer size for our island.  It states they are 10 inches in depth at the bottom of the bar stool. I even asked a question on here & they responded that it was 10 inches.   It is not .. they are 12 inches at the bottom in depth.   Not too big of a deal though but still was one of the main reasons I picked these.   Also 2 of my 3 were fine but 1 of the saddle seats did not have holes drilled in the appropriate spots to take a screw.  Called & they said I will get a replacement in a few weeks for the saddle top.