I bought two of these. One regular and one open box saving $150 on it. They were delivered the same day so I have no idea which was which. I've had them for about 6 weeks now and one of them looks beautiful. The leather is taking on the that old-timey, worn look that was in the description and that I expected. The other one looks like it's been through the wars. The leather is now so worn out (and not in an attractive way) that it looks like I found it in a dumpster. I tried using leather conditioning wipes and it looked better for about 30 minutes before turning back into a pumpkin. Otherwise, the chairs are pretty comfortable, although kind of small. The studded tinted copper wrapping around the back is a great look. 4 stars is the average score I would give the two chairs. 5 for one and 3 for the other.