Let's face it, with cats it's always a 50/50 gamble they'll like anything you buy. Luckily, my house panther loves this perch! He's about 13 lbs and a big boy; based on other reviews sounded like this would be big enough to provide two comfortable platforms to sleep on and that's 100% been the case. He loves both sitting and lying on it to look out the slider, but also sleeps on both platforms when it's time for an afternoon snooze. It's very stable when he's jumping up and down and appears to be a very sturdy construction. 
He hasn't really scratched it at all; another all-sisal post I have that's a bit taller is more his style. But I'm happy there's some sisal on this perch in case the panther wants to scratch it. He couldn't care less about the dangling toy (a jingle bell in a plastic ball, not the feather thing pictured on the website) and I'm going to cut it down. Another cat may love it, though