I find these shower rings to be quite attractive but not as impressed functionally. I use them for my father's shower and my daughter's shower. Every time I go in either bathroom I find that a ring or two has become detached from the shower bar. They have both complained that these rings do not keep the curtain on consistently, that they easily fall off. I will have to find time to research a more secure shower ring but in the meantime I keep them mainly for its eye appeal.