The whole set is good, and all the yellow handles are just beautiful. However, the quality of the shovel was very poor. It lasted less than 24 h. The rod and the shovel were lightly riveted but not as a whole piece or welded together. Cheap design results in poor quality. The rivet melt/broke when I used the shovel to remove ash/hot charcoal out from my stove insert. Very disappointed with it as all the other three tools and the stand seem pretty good. I am gonna ask for return and refund.