I would honestly give it 5 stars if there wasn't a large crack on the underneath the top of the desk- you cannot see it and it doesn't impact the integrity of the desk itself- at least that I can tell.  

The desk took about 2 1/2 hours to put together with just one person- would probably be good to have two putting it together as it is VERY heavy. But all in all its beautiful piece and other than the crack under the top of the desk it is perfect. Goes very well with our décor and seems to be quite sturdy.