The tile matches the sample we ordered previously. Extra was sent because I'm sure breakage was expected. All of the tile in one of the originally shipped boxes was broken. The replacement process was very easy and we didn't have to return the broken tile. Two boxes just arrived as replacement. Good thing there is extra because 1/2 had chipped corners and one box is a different color granite. Still happy overall because replacement was easy and we have more than enough for our project.