I'd really give it about 4.5 stars.  Good quality for the price.  Like the ability to lock it.  Looks nice.  Sturdy so far.  The only thing keeping it from getting 5 stars is the inability to hold bottles with a slightly larger diameter (I had 3 that were just a tiny bit to wide).  I anticipated this based on other reviews that I'd read, so I wasn't surprised.  However a few slots for larger bottles would make this a 5 star product.  If you're thinking about it, just buy it.  :)

Pros: Great value, no assembly, appearance, locking ability, sturdy (so far)
Cons: doesn't fit larger bottles, doesn't come with a coordinating lock